Showing posts with label Ronald Reagan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ronald Reagan. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Trend for percent change to personal income quarterly hit the wall in 3Q1981

 



And another one: Trend for percent change even for real disposable personal income is also up until 1984, and down thereafter

 Something about that Reagan era. What could it be?

 



Oh no, not another one: The trend for percent change in personal income was up until Ronald Reagan in 1984, and down since then

 Pesky facts.

pesky fuel rod



 

Mark Hemingway might as well be Bill Clinton

It's not 1992 anymore, Mark.

  

Saturday, October 31, 2026

Michael Lind and the tariff advocates are delusional when they say tariffs will get manufacturing to come back to the United States

During the heyday of American tariffs, tariff revenues were tiny and went to fund a tiny federal government.

From 1880 to 1910, federal spending grew from about $300 million nominal to $800+ million, and tariff revenues more or less tracked it to pay those bills.


 

At the same time the rich risked their own money to build US manufacturing, and the tax code was uniquely arranged to reward them for it.

To put it simply, until Reagan we taxed ordinary income at high marginal rates, while income from long term capital investment received relatively preferential tax treatment. That investment translated directly into American manufacturing, higher-paying American jobs, and robust economic growth.

High marginal ordinary income tax rates, which dominated the tax code from WWI except during the roaring 1920s, were first brought down by JFK to 70% from 91%, then to 50% by Reagan I, and finally to 28% by Reagan II. Democrats subsequently lifted these into the high 30s where they are now. 

Capital gains rates of 25%, which persisted throughout the period, suddenly lost much of their appeal because the spreads closed. The new arbitrage which opened up because of globalization was between costly labor at home and cheap labor abroad, which the rich then exploited to get even wealthier.

For those of us who lived through this period, it was accompanied by the constant drum beat of one business after another closing up its domestic operations and moving them abroad, leaving a steady stream of workers behind who were forced to find usually less well paying work here.

We did this to ourselves and called it conservatism. 

Michael Lind here is delusional about how to turn back this clock:

Tariffs — taxes on imports — are a means to the end of “reshoring” manufacturing in America. By making some imports more expensive, Trump hopes to expand the market for those products at home for American manufacturers.

Apart from not working (!), this makes the consumer pay the bill instead of placing the risk where it belongs, with the capitalists, who have the capital!

You will never accomplish with tariffs, whose arena is now much too small, what you can with the stick of high ordinary income tax rates, high capital gains taxes on income from US investment abroad, and the carrot of relatively lower capital gains taxes on income from domestic investment.

We need to attract capital back to the United States and give it preferential treatment in the tax code while penalizing in a relative way the income received from foreign sources and from high ordinary incomes received at home.

Ordinary incomes up to $101,082/$134,776 single/married-filing-jointly in Sep 2026 should be free of federal tax, but anything higher should be progressively and steeply taxed.

Capital gains tax rates should follow the reverse course: steep taxes on income from capital held up to a year, and progressively lower taxes on income from capital held 2, 3, 5, 7, 10, 20, and 30 years.

In such a tax environment, corporate taxes would be redundant, unnecessary, and counterproductive. 

Meanwhile 10 years of the Trump tariff regime are not working to revive domestic manufacturing, and the long term comparison with the pre-Reagan past remains negative.




 

Thursday, October 29, 2026

Real GDP at 3.4% in the first estimate for 3Q2026 is good, but the trend since 2Q1983 is still not like the robust post-war

 I'd rather have the economy trending to 5.4% than the one trending to 2.2%.

Trump Republicanism overpromised and has not delivered. It has been nothing more than an irritable mental gesture toward Reaganism.

Reagan Republicanism, as a form of liberalism, underestimated the power of evil in human nature. It sincerely but naively thought that everything would turn out just hunky dory if you let people decide what to do with their own money, and give them more of it.

Well, they miss-allocated it, just in a more respectable form than the corner beggar. 

The post-war consensus had kept ordinary income tax rates high and arbitraged that against relatively lower long term capital gains tax rates which benefited the domestic investment which produced the jobs, marriages, durable goods purchases, and homes young people can only dream about today. In short, the GDP.

The high ordinary income tax rates went bye-bye, and the money went where it was willed in an orgy of individualism. The big money got miss-allocated in the dot-com bubble, and globalism arrived just in the nick of time to rescue it, fleeing abroad. As a result middle classes were built elsewhere while the middle class at home withered. It now had to work two jobs and have smaller, or no, families. And cultural commentators seriously wonder how identity came to be questioned to the point of gender.

We can quantify this social disaster in the form of $10.5 trillion of missing real GDP in 3Q2026 since 3Q1983.

We have today $24.611 trillion of real GDP, having grown at a compound annual rate of 2.733% for the 43 years since 1983.

At the 36-year post-war CAGR of 3.585%, however, real GDP would be $35.104 trillion instead, 42.6% better.

Nothing guarantees that growth would have continued at the old post-war rate had the Reagan Revolution never occurred, but that doesn't change the fact that he sold his program in the belief that America's best days were not behind her.

Arguing at this long remove that Reaganism hasn't really been tried reminds me of nothing so much as Keynesianism redivivus. And AOC thinks his first name is Milton.

Republicans today are oblivious to all of this, and the only Democrat who comes close to understanding it that I know of is Rahm Emanuel, but the Democrat Party of today openly hates the Joos.

We are, as the kids like to say, totally screwed.

 





Thursday, October 8, 2026

Two cheers for Rahm Emanuel

Monday, October 5, 2026

Globalization obviously hit America hardest after 1999 when total hours worked by all workers as a percentage of civilian population plunged as manufacturing jobs leaving the country became a flood, but people pretend not to see

1970-1985 sucked pretty bad though, long before the current suckiness which tastes like nothing so much as that era.

A country that doesn't work is a poor country.

But of course globalization after 1984 meant the good paying manufacturing jobs started to dry up because patriotic American businessmen relocated them to cheaper labor countries in East Asia.

😏 

 





Wednesday, September 30, 2026

Oh look, I found our GDP missing since Reagan

 We're missing $11 trillion real GDP since Reagan.

 


Is the Trump economic policy doing anything positive for economic growth since 2016?

 Only if you squint.

The trend line inclines slightly from 1.3% seasonally adjusted annual rate in mid-2016 to 2.5% in mid-2026.

That's just part of a larger negative trend, however, since the Reagan Revolution in the 1980s. With the exception of the pandemic circus in 2020, quarterly real GDP hasn't been close to 10% since the mid-1980s.

We have fallen from a great height.

 

Trump era since 2016
Reagan era since 1983
Pre-Reagan era




 

Thursday, September 3, 2026

Marco Rubio is not far from the kingdom of God

 Secretary Rubio: America Made A "Terrible Mistake" Deindustrializing For Globalization "Fantasy"

The Reagan tax revolution made America ripe for globalization, but you can't explain that to a mouthbreather.

The goal wasn't globalization.  

After all the dotcom malinvestment, the entry of China into the WTO opened a door to a ready, welcome, and fateful solution which became globalization, funded by oodles of low marginal ordinary income tax rates.

We need more philosophers, and fewer Rubios. 

 


 

Thursday, August 27, 2026

Real GDP today might have been $35 trillion instead of $24 trillion had it not been for Ronald Reagan

Real GDP today might have been $35 trillion instead of $24 trillion had it not been for Ronald Reagan. 

From 1Q1947 to 1Q1984, real GDP grew at a compound annual rate of 3.585% from $2.18268 trillion to $8.03484 trillion.

Since 1Q1984 through 2Q2026, updated yesterday, the compound annual growth rate fell to 2.651% so that real GDP today is $24.26961 trillion when at the previous rate it might have achieved $35.58524 trillion.

The 26% cut to the growth rate resulted in underperformance of nearly 32%, represented by $11.3 trillion in missing real GDP after 42.25 years.

Did recipients of massive ordinary income tax rate cuts know best what to do with their own money?

The answer in China is Shì de.

  

The calculation is 35585.24 = 8034.84 * (1 + 0.03585) ^42.25

 




 

Sunday, August 23, 2026

Increases to the Federal Debt since 4Q2000, as horrible as they may seem, are part of a macroeconomic growth trend for federal debt which is lower since 1984

If the macroeconomic growth trend for federal debt as a percentage of GDP were higher, however, that would be different, but that too was arrested in the early 1980s.

Of course, that picture would look so, so much better if the real GDP growth trend since 1983 weren't so disappointing.

The Reagan Revolution delivered on reducing the federal debt growth trend, but not on increasing the economic growth trend. 

The biggest failure of the Reagan Revolution was its misplaced faith in human nature.

We liked hearing that we knew best what to do with our own money. "Tax cuts will boost economic growth". It made us feel so good, so optimistic.

But owners of capital promptly pocketed the windfalls and ultimately invested them elsewhere.

 

Federal Debt:

4Q2000 $5.662T

4Q2008 $10.699T: +$5.037T (+88.9%) Bush 43

4Q2016 $19.976T: +$9.277T (+86.7%) Obama

4Q2020 $27.747T: +$7.771T (+38.9%) Trump I

4Q2024 $36.218T: +$8.471T (+30.5%) Biden

Now $40T: +$3.782T (+10.4%) Trump II to date

 


 

Thursday, August 20, 2026

Larry Kudlow is back touting a non-existent booming economy just like he did during Trump's first administration

 This Is the Best 'Hard Goods' Boom in Decades

... Tuesday’s industrial production report showed back-to-back gains in June and July for both total production and manufacturing production. ...

Larry is rightly happy about the increase in the durable manufacturing index. 

No doubt about it, it is up, but notice that it is still not as high as it was in Trump 2018 or Obama 2014. 

More importantly, percent change in the index for 1H2026 was 1.94, lower than the 2.28 in 1H2018 when Trump was president the first time.

But this isn't an economic boom, and neither was that. 

Those are welcome highpoints but in a long-term trend all down hill since the 1980s when Reagan was president, and no one asks why.

Kudlow & Co. never go back in the data as far as they should, even though they served in the Reagan Revolution and touted the results for the economy of the posthumous JFK tax cut in the Revenue Act of 1964, which cut the top marginal rate from 91% to 70%.

Today they use these data sets which go back only to the beginning of 1972, but even at that there is a giant durable goods growth spike of 9.02% in 2H1983 which we have been unable to reproduce since then, which should make them ask themselves, What went wrong?, but it doesn't.

Socrates said that the unexamined life isn't worth living.

So let's examine it.

Robust post-war growth is a truism which is true!

Industrial production generally, and for manufacturing specifically, grew robustly year over year, and the trend for those growth rates was itself strongly positive, as the chart for 1948 to 1984 shows.

But look at what happens after 1984. 

You still get positive growth rates year over year, but not as robust as before, and the trend for those growth rates becomes strongly negative.

Something changed in the 1980s to cause this.

I say it's the Reagan Revolution in ordinary income tax rate reductions which caused this, not because tax cuts for rich people is bad, but because Reagan unintentionally sabotaged the tax rate arbitrage which before those tax cuts existed had pushed rich people for decades to make long term capital investments here at home in order to get low capital gains taxes in return.

In other words, Reagan destroyed the negative incentives which drove domestic investment. Take away the penalty of high ordinary income tax rates, and suddenly there's no reason to plow your money into the investments which drive business, jobs, and GDP, especially as enthusiasm for regulations of all kinds began to grow and hamstring profits. 

The new tax cut windfalls freed up a lot of money to seek return wherever it could be found, and in the aftermath of the Reagan era that money increasingly went abroad. For people who lived through it, the one persistent theme of the business news was one business after another closing up shop in America and moving production overseas. After China entered the WTO, the steady departure of businesses from America became a flood.

And that's why that last chart, for 1984 to the present, looks like hell.

It has nothing to do with the U.S. Dollar being the world's reserve currency either. That is the dumbest thing I've heard in years, and I can't tell you how amusing that is coming out of the mouth of a Yalie. I guess they don't teach 'em at Yale that the dollar was the world's reserve currency 1948-1984.

I am not an economist. I do not know how to wave a magic wand of policy to make it all right again. 

I am just a scholar in the humanities who wanted to know what turned my world upside down in 2007 and why I and millions like me have never recovered.

I have made a life for myself in spite of it all, as people do, but I tell you what, America was pretty great once, so don't tell me this is an economic boom.

I knew the economic boom. The economic boom was a friend of mine. And Larry, this isn't an economic boom.

 

 

Wednesday, August 19, 2026

Industrial production missed the consensus estimate yesterday, so they trotted out Larry Kudlow to tell you otherwise lol

 For month over month in July, the consensus estimate was for +0.3%. Instead we got +0.2%.

Meanwhile the big picture shows, like so many indicators, that industrial production hit the big brick wall of Reaganism in 1984.

Post-war industrial production grew handsomely and its growth rate trended upward from 1948 to 1984, but not after.

Why is that?

I think it's because the incentive to invest in domestic industry went away because of the Reagan tax revolution.

Up to that time, high ordinary income tax rates had pushed owners of capital to invest in America for decades because by doing so they could take advantage of relatively much lower long term capital gains tax rates when they wanted to take income. After the dramatic Reagan cuts to ordinary income tax rates, that arbitrage disappeared. From that time onward owners of capital, now flush with cash from taking income at low ordinary income tax rates year upon year, found it more advantageous to invest abroad where low labor costs and unregulated markets promised even more fabulous returns on investment as America hobbled itself with regulation at home. The exit of businesses of all sizes from the United States to East Asia which began from this time turned into a flood after China was admitted into the WTO in 2001.

But today J. D. Vance thinks the U.S. Dollar's status as the world's reserve currency is the cause of all our problems.

If you want to know what makes me despair, that's it.

The following news story was more accurate than Kudlow. 

US: Industrial Production Up Again in July as Modest Manufacturing Recovery Continues 


Thursday, June 25, 2026

The current economic growth rate continues to underperform the post-war compound annual growth rate to Reagan by 42%

 1Q2026 real GDP in the third estimate today came in at an annualized rate of 2.1%.

The first estimate was 2.0%. The second was 1.6%.

The revision back up again and a little higher was "primarily reflecting a downward revision to imports", which are a subtraction from GDP.

Expect higher GDP in 2Q on the strength of oil exports. 

The post-war economic growth rate to Reagan was 3.64% compound annual vs. 2.1% now.

The compound annual rate 2017-2025 was 2.48%.

Trump is even underperforming himself by 15%. 

 


 

Monday, May 11, 2026

US economic growth peaked during the Reagan administration because America is a debt-based economy and we turned our backs on the formula during it

 The trend for the growth of the total universe of US debt, TCMDO or total credit market debt outstanding, rolled over after 1985, one year after GDP did.

TCMDO is the real money, almost $108 trillion at the end of 2025. In 1985 it was $9 trillion.

M2 was merely $22 trillion at the end of 2025. 

TCMDO is the sum total of debt expansion throughout the sectors of the economy.

Historically, most people have experienced it this way.

You get a full time job, which itself was created by a business selling debt in the form of stocks and bonds in order to expand its operations and future profits, and you go buy a house, putting down $100k on a $500k property. The bank loans you the $400k through fractional reserve lending on a small portion of its reserves but secured by the house. That new money is created out of thin air but is actually represented by the "guaranteed" future income stream of your job for 30 years, because you're a smart, reliable guy who never misses a day of work. TCMDO expands, and expands some more each time this happens.

When the conditions disappear for full time job creation, the process slows down. You can see the decline in the growth of the economy in the decline of the growth of the debt. Yes, everything is still growing, but not as vigorously.

Full time as a percent of population peaked 26 years ago, in 2000, at 53.55%, but retested the 1975 low of 46.74% in 2010 and 2011 at 46.97%, back-to-back years in the Late Great Recession.

Housing strength persisted in the immediate post-Reagan period on the illusory basis of windfalls from massive ordinary income tax cuts combined with the demographic peaking of the 1957 Baby Boom turning 40 in 1997 driving demand, but the hollowing out of the economy had already begun with the move of 20,000 manufacturers abroad after the 1986 tax reform.

Early warning signs began flashing already during the Clinton era.

Clinton immediately raised taxes in 1993 after he promised not to raise them in 1992, began a long series of cuts to federal government employment, and gutted the US Navy.

Americans were already struggling at the time and ominously tapped housing equity to sustain their middle class standard of living. Owners' Equity in Real Estate averaged 70% 1982-1986 inclusive, but plunged ten points within a decade to 60% 1996-1999 inclusive.

Homes had become piggy banks, preparing the way for 1997, the year Clinton and the Republicans went further still and turned homes into mere commodities, which in turn prepared the way for the housing catastrophe of 2008. From 1997 a flood of 70,000 more manufacturers began moving out as globalization kicked into high gear and China gained admission to the WTO in 2001.

Almost no one today wants to say out loud how unpatriotic this whole business was. 

Reagan tried to convince us that we know best what to do with our own money, and we promptly turned around and staked our fortunes on foreign investment, not domestic.

Libertarianism is a lie.  

Today you will be hard-pressed to identify a major manufacturing concern with 100% of its operations in the US. Tesla is a standout (heavily subsidized by the federal government!), but other than that most of the businesses which remain patriotically committed to the American idea are pretty small beer compared with how it used to be. 

The formerly domestic debt expansion was exported abroad, creating middle classes where none existed before, especially in East Asia, and doing so cost businesses A LOT less, the key attraction for them.

As a result, enormous profits accrued to the owners of capital while wage earners here struggled to maintain the American dream. Wealth inequality soared, and now our children are 40 before they buy their first home.   

TCMDO grew at a compound annual rate of 8.355% 1945-1985, but at only 6.398% 1985-2025. The change from optimism to pessimism can be traced in the trend lines.

Continued growth of TCMDO at the former rate but after 1985 would have yielded TCMDO at the end of 2025 of $223 trillion, or 106% more "money" than we actually have.

$115 trillion is "missing", or at least something like that. We will never know for sure, but some of us can still imagine because we watched the great betrayal actually happen.

This is why I say socialism is the future, not because I want it or because I think it will work.

People are going to figure this out eventually, get angry, and do the wrong thing, just like we did during the Reagan administration.